Ok, I must be doing something stupid here...
I've created a category page here: http://www.gracelandcampus.org/category/spiritual-faq
and stickied a post with some instructions. Yet it doesn't seem to be working.
I also tried this: astickypostorderer but it affected my entire blog, whereas I only want that post stickied within that category.
Right now I am using the List category posts WordPress Plugin, but when I added any sort order (eg sortby=name sort=asc) it doesn't change anything.
Thanks in advance,