I had a look at your site, and it seems you've recently changed your site URL from theokayestmom.org to emilythomaswrites.com. When you did so, you created a new set of stats and subscribers for the new site URL.
As of today, both domains return results:
Could you set up a redirection from one domain to the other, to avoid duplicate content and penalties from search engines like Google?
Once you've done so, let me know and I'll merge your stats and subscribers into the final domain of your choice.