Standalone services add/remove not saving

I’m attempting to add several buttons to the bottom of my posts–not just the traditional sharing rectangle, but standalone buttons with Facebook, Twitter, Google+, and Pinterest.

When I click to add these, all is fine and they are selected. However, when I click “save changes” they are not saved.

Any tips on how to get this to work? (It worked last week but when I changed the settings from appearing in both the top and the bottom of posts this bug cropped up.)

http://wordpress.org/extend/plugins/add-to-any/