I'm the admin and I have a registered user who's been having problems logging in. However, when I change the password for this user via the Dashboard and try logging in with it, I get 'Sorry, that email isn't registered.' This doesn't jive with the following: When I request a new password for this email, I don't get an error message, but when I request a password for an email I definitely know isn't registered, I get "ERROR: There is no user registered with that email address."
Not sure if this is a problem since upgrading to WP 3.5.1 or using Email Login plugin version 4.5. I have a number of other plugins I use, but no problem prior to WP 3.5.1.
What's strange is that when I google 'sorry, that email isn't registered' there are no google results, as if no one else is getting this error message.