SEO Title Tags plugin step 4

Step 4 of installation of the SEO Title Tag plugin for WordPress is something I couldn’t find in my WordPress site admin. For instance, I didn’t see anything called ‘presentation,’ and when I went to my ‘theme editor,’ nothing matched ‘title’ in the header section.
I basically need help with where to do step 4 from http://wordpress.org/extend/plugins/seo-title-tag/installation/ below. I use Atahualpa theme, but I do not update because updating destroys parts of my graphics and layout, so I have version Atahualpa 3.6.4.
Here is step 4 for your convenience and for clarity as to what I need help with:

“Under Presentation -> Theme Editor in the WordPress admin, select “Header” from the list and replace <title><?php bloginfo('name'); wp_title(); ?></title> (or whatever you have in your <title> container) with<title><?php if (function_exists('seo_title_tag')) { seo_title_tag(); } else { bloginfo('name'); wp_title();} ?></title>

[Please post code snippets between backticks or use the code button.]

Thanks!