Self hosted WP issue/ Hello Bar (sometimes) not displaying

Hey there,
I am trying to utilize a Hello Bar via the WP Hello Bar plugin.
I seem to be running into an issue where when the
Logged In Users Display HelloBar for logged in users.
is checked, I can see the Hello Bar. When it is not checked, I can not.
My understanding or lineage of thought would be that when the box is checked only WP users that are logged in would be able to view the Hello Bar, and when unchecked, all visitors to the site would be able to see it, which is what I would like.
However, when the box is unclicked, the Hello Bar disappears.
Does that make sense?
If so, is it possible for me to do something to resolve this so all visitors to the site, regardless of if they are logged into WP, can see the Hello Bar?

Thank you in advance for your time and help.
http://www.pamelamalo.com/

http://wordpress.org/extend/plugins/wp-hello-bar/