Select Content restriction makes age gate disappear

First off, let me say that I love your plugin. The ability to restrict certain categories, etc, is awesome! It’s exactly what I was looking for! However, I’ve been testing via an incognito browser and when I turn on ‘Restrict Selected Content’, the age gate disappears completely, and I’m able to see everything, even the categories that are supposed to be hidden behind an age-gate.

I have test posts up for the time being, in two different categories (Here) One that IS and one that ISN’T supposed to be visible to under-age viewers.

I only want the age-gate on one page, really. Not even the main one. That way they can choose whether or not they want to read with the adult stuff or not.

The page I need help with: [log in to see the link]