***** (<-- 5 Stars)
This plugin is not listed here at WordPress.org. You need to get it from the Blue Letter Bible Website -- But it works PERFECTLY.
The reason I am posting this is that there is no well-functioning Bible verse tagging plugin I was able to find here. I wanted to share it with other people who might be looking for a Bible tagging plugin that works and maintained.
So, I went looking and found that BLB had its own. Downloaded the zip file, unpacked it . . . had an uploading problem, but used FTP and got it done. You can select your preferred version. It is lightening fast and accurate. It's the best I have used (out of 4 different ones).
Here is a page for a sample: TEST
Here is the page for the plugin (the download link is in the lower half of the page at the top of the install instruction): BLB Tagger