Restricted Content for Logged In Users

The plug in “WP Hide Post” appears to be extremely close to what we’re looking for. Currently we are using “Content Restrict by OTP”, but when we restrict the content for logged in users only, it continues to show up on the home page under latest posts. “WP Hide Post” is perfect because it doesn’t display on the main page, but it has too many options. All we need to do is restrict the content from the main page, as well as logged out users, but continue to allow access and display on the main page to logged in users. Is there any way of adding the functionality of “WP Hide Post” when selecting “Yes” option for content restrict in “Content Restrict by OTP” to logged in users only? Or does anyone know of a plug in that does what I’m talking about?