Thank you both for your response. The link to the page displaying that the event is closed is here: http://www.thepsychiclife.com/events/spirit-guides-i/
I'm not sure how to include a screenshot in this post. The settings for this particular event indicate that the event is open, that bookings will cut off on 11/29, that there are still 19 spaces available.
What I've done is to create this sample event and register for it while logged into WordPress. Then, I log out and check the event as a guest. That's when it shows that the event is closed. When I log back in, it shows that I've already registered for that event. There is no one else testing the event, and there are still plenty of spaces left open.
Does that help?