Redirect after Login Not working

I’m using the shortcode for Login + Redirect. However, after logging in, the current page that I was on is reloading and the pop up is reappearing.

The popup lives on this page: https://expungeonline.com/indiana/my-account-indiana-register

Here is the shortcode: [wpmem_form login redirect_to=”https://expungeonline.com/indiana/my-account-indiana/”%5D

After logging in, the popup just reloads onto this original page: https://expungeonline.com/indiana/my-account-indiana-register

The page I need help with: [log in to see the link]