[plugin: WPAU] Cannot login after DB upgrade

I’ve never been able to use WordPress Automatic Upgrade and get a complete and proper installation. The most recent time I’ve tried to upgrade using WPAU I am instructed to login after my Database upgrade. I go to login and I receive a message saying that my password is incorrect. I re-type my password to double check and receive the same message. After attempting a password reset I am still unable to log back in to my admin panel to complete the installation. I even tried the emergency PW reset page and still have no luck

Is there something I’m doing wrong or am I just destined to upgrade manually? Any help would be greatly appreciated.