[Plugin: WP Mail SMTP] Wrong Reply To Address

My SMTP username is showing up as the reply to address whenever I send an email using the plugin. I have both the “From Name” and the “From Address” filled out and I have tried both checking and unchecking the “Set the return-path to match the From Email” checkbox but nothing seems to fix the problem.

I am using a Gmail email address for my SMTP account

I am experiencing this issue both when I use the “Send Test Email” and when emails are sent from other plugins (Gravity Forms).

http://wordpress.org/extend/plugins/wp-mail-smtp/