[Plugin: Facebook Fan Box] Won't Show Stream

I am wracking my brain on this.

I have two sites:

http://www.jj-polo.themetrologyadvantage.com

and

http://www.SouthBayPolo.com

Both have the Facebook Fan Box Plugin.
Both are configured the same in the widget.

The FB sites that they pull from are:

https://www.facebook.com/pages/JJ-Polo/277841972241093
for the JJ-Polo site

and

https://www.facebook.com/southbaypolo
for the South Bay Polo site.

The South Bay Polo site will not show a proper stream, but it does show one post about someone being tagged in April. Weird thing is, I created the page on May 7th?

Why does one site work perfectly and the other doesn’t? Do I have to set something up on facebook – permissions or something.

Any help is appreciated.