[Plugin: AddThis] showing an extra/incorrect bookmark graphic

I picked small toolbox to show at the end of pages, archives, categories, and posts. Yet when I look up a category, it shows a small tool box and a large share bookmark. Also when I do a search, I see a large share bookmark (not what I have selected in Settings) That doesn’t make sense to show something I didn’t choose.

Search page problem:
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v313/k0buta/save.png

Blog post problem:
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v313/k0buta/two-bookmarks.png

I may have to mess around with adding it manually and hiding the extra bookmark w/ css because this makes no sense to me.