We created payment pages with s2Member PayPal Pro Forms.
We copied the shortcode verbatim and pasted it in the page.
Now when anyone uses the page it sends them to PayPal but there is no subscription data. In the past the PayPal page would repeat the subscription information given in the pro forms set up.
ALL plugins have been disabled.
Literally, ONLY s2Member is active.
The theme is set to default 2014.