This problem is really eluding me as well as the Theme creator which is why I am here.
The theme I used is 'Made' and I am on WP 3.5.
When I use pagination while creating a post, and preview, the first page previews find but all after (2, 3, 4, 5) return a 404 and are not shown.
I have exhausted my search on Google.
Thanks ahead for any help and I will willingly post any needed code.