I don't know which part I had messed up, but when I click on "Previous Page" which takes me to Page 2 of the list of entries, I only see the same entries as on main page displayed.
The URL changes and contains ...page/2/ at the end, Title tag changes as well and contains - Part 2 - behind the title. The only catch is that the same posts that appear on the main page are displayed. It does not display older posts. Anyone know what it is I have messed up that content of each older page displays the same, latest posts?