Hi,
Your theme can be a problem.
Broken Link Manager working principle;
– Backlink (of example : http://yourdomain/xxx) is broken go to 404.php (standard WordPress operation)
– if you add redirected url for this link (http://yourdomain/xxx). It will redirect whit 301 medhot to redirected url (and save to LOG)
– if you don’t add to redirected url for broken link (http://yourdomain/xxx) only save to broken link in LOG and will show to 404 page.
Maybe your theme secand time working 404.php. I will If you get a result please write. Just in case I’ll test a few different themes.
Im using a paid theme from codecanyon but would be happy to send you a copy to test with.
I have used “Redirection” for 4+ years but hate the interface and feel that they don’t do a great job at logging the 404s. Instead of logging each link once with a count of how many times it was tried, each attempt is a seperately logged 404.
I like yours and am using it despite the double count, but would be much happier if it was accurate for my theme, so if it will help email me and I can send you a copy of the theme danieliser at wizardinternetsolutions.com