Support » Plugin: Sitemap Generator » not as good

Viewing 5 replies - 1 through 5 (of 5 total)
  • Plugin Author Marco Beierer

    (@mbsec)

    Hi avanceinno

    Can you maybe tell me which generator you mean and elaborate a bit what it does better and also explain what your requirements are? Whether something is better or worse always depends on the requirements of a user.

    The Sitemap Generator has its strengths and weaknesses as every other generator has, but if you not elaborate, this comment helps nobody to make a decision, it just harms this plugin and it makes me ask, why you have just registered to leave such a meaningless and harmful review?

    I would really appreciate if you could reply and give more details so that we can have a short discussion that really helps users to decide which plugin is better for them…

    Best regards
    Marco

    Moderator Jan Dembowski

    (@jdembowski)

    Forum Moderator and Brute Squad

    Can you maybe tell me which generator you mean

    Nah, don’t do that. The reviews are not for “This other plugin is better”. And if someone needs support then please start a support topic.

    https://wordpress.org/support/plugin/mb-sitemap-generator/#new-post

    Plugin Author Marco Beierer

    (@mbsec)

    Hi Jan @jdembowski

    Mmh, but is the intention of reviews not to help interested users make a decision? From this point of view, such a review doesn’t add any value and a comparison would be much better for the users so that they can make a decision easier?

    For example if @avanceinno says that my generator does not have feature x, but generator y does, everybody who needs x knows, that he/she has not to try my generator at all.

    And such a review would also give me the change to highlight the advantages of the generator compared to generator y.

    A review without explanation just harms my generator but doesn’t add any value at all…

    Moderator Jan Dembowski

    (@jdembowski)

    Forum Moderator and Brute Squad

    Mmh, but is the intention of reviews not to help interested users make a decision?

    The reviews are intended for feedback. If this review becomes a support topic then I will archive it or close it.

    Replying to feedback is good and encouraged. But sadly, some users use the reviews to extort support and that’s not cool and gets removed when found.

    And such a review would also give me the change to highlight the advantages of the generator compared to generator y.

    Which is a great story for your blog. But the review here has to remain about this plugin and it is NOT about any other plugins.

    Also don’t @ me.

    Plugin Author Marco Beierer

    (@mbsec)

    All right, I’m not sure what I should learn from such a feedback, but okay, if that’s the way it works, it is like it is…

Viewing 5 replies - 1 through 5 (of 5 total)
  • The topic ‘not as good’ is closed to new replies.