I'm sorry for being a broken record. I keep trying to fix the star problem on my website, but every couple days or so I keep coming back and posting in support to see if anyone has any advice. If I can't fix this I'm going to have to go buy a premium photo battle plugin or something so I figured I'd give it a couple more tries. Shaun's given me a few things to try (deactivate other plugins or swap the theme), but I haven't gotten any results from deactivating and since it is a buddypress site I don't want to play with themes too much. That seems to mess with the site in my past experience.
If anyone has found solutions to anything like this or if anyone is willing to look at my page and help me find some answers I'd appreciate it a lot. Will even send you some stickers from our site :)