As for the site, I think you did a great job of making it very “wow-ish”. Even the background color is close to what Blizz uses.
My only big concern is readability. It’s hard to read the white text on the dark burnt orange on the left nav.
Additionally, the tables your WOTLK post are all over the place so I would either fix the tables or just use the insert media tool for the ones with pictures. The table you’re using for system requirements is white with light grey text, big problem in so many ways there.
Lastly, and probably worst of all, I can’t read the star ratings at all. It’s yellow text on a white background.
Eternalism, I would have a look at the line-spacing used on your site. If you make this slightly bigger the readability of your site will improve. I would also concentrate on getting the code on the site to validate, both the HTML and CSS show numerous errors.
The site is very nice and it is definitely worthwhile the bit of effort it will take to make it even better.