very nice visually, even though I dont care for the wood-ish look too much.
I'll skip looking for anything to 'criticize' for 1 main reason..
Its obvious you spent alot of time on it. (Unique sites take work, time, and effort (and love) and anyone thats ever NOT used a downloaded theme knows this.
In my book, even if there was a garish error in the middle of the page, i still like it more than 99.99999999999999999999999999999999999999 of the so-called sites people have been putting up here lately.
Sure, not everyone can create a theme, but damn straight, a lot of people can break them.