Lost Jetpack Site Stats and Subscribers

Hello,
I recently disabled and re-enabled Jetpack to troubleshoot my site, and in doing so, lost my old Jetpack site stats and 34 subscribers.

The subscribers are still listed under “Users” but not showing up in Jetpack > Site Stats. So… when I publish a new post, it doesn’t get sent to the list of 34 subscribers.

Please note: The other change I made to the site was that I created a new blog page: http://www.artofthecell.com/johns-blog. The OLD blog page is: http://www.artofthecell.com/blog. I did this because I was having trouble styling the first blog page… so I just made a new one. I wonder if this is causing a conflict. If so, I’m not sure how to start fixing the problem.

I would like to activate the subscribers as well as get back the old site stats, if possible.

Thanks in advance.
Irene

p.s. I’ve seen other similar topics, but they seem to be resolved by an administrator.