Like Button site vs post count

On this post the Like Button is counting likes for livingears.com: http://livingears.com/2012/08/recycle-culture-unicorn-kid/

(Another example: http://livingears.com/2012/11/andy-stott-sleepless/)

On this post the Like Button counts the likes for the specific post: http://livingears.com/2012/11/livingears-dropbox-6-now-available/

(Another example, this time a page: http://livingears.com/dropbox/)

I would like the count to be for the individual post, not the domain. Is that possible?

http://wordpress.org/extend/plugins/twitter-facebook-google-plusone-share/