I tried the Facebook Like Button plugin, and found that while it allowed me to "share" a link to the (non-facebook) page on my facebook page, allowing me to add a comment, it did not place a "like" under my "Likes" on my facebook page. It showed up under "Likes Recently", but not the "Likes" above, if you know what I mean. Is this something your plugin should be able to do, but I'm just not configuring it correctly?
I want it to work like the one on this page: http://turnerphotographics.com/portraits/senior/
This one both puts an entry with the link and comment in the timeline, but also puts a thumbnail under "Likes"
It would also be nice if I could choose a thumbnail as well.