Via Firebug I can see that all BadgeOS tasks and badges use the Post template create the badges. All the example badges and tasks that came with the plugin show the Leave a Reply comment field however, when I create my own taks or badges the Leave a Reply field does not show up. Also, I made some changes to one of the example badges (change how badge was earned: from "Completing Steps" to "Submission") which then caused the Leave a Reply field disappeared.
I've change the theme and the problem remains. I don't believe there are any conflicts with other plugins since some of the badges have the comment field and some don't and because that one example badge I changed once had the field and then didn't.
Any help with this issue would be greatly appreciate. Below are links to two of the badges currently on my site. One example badge and one that I made.