Could you try to install this Jetpack add-on?
http://wordpress.org/plugins/follow-button-for-jetpack/
If Jetpack is activated and connected to your WordPress.com account, this plugin should work just fine.
If that doesn’t help, could you post your site URL here so I can have a look?
If you want it to remain private, you can also contact us via this contact form:
http://jetpack.me/contact-support/
Hey Jeremy! Thanks for responding!
I think I did install it. At least I clicked on the plug-in from my dashboard, clicked “install now,” and it is “active” according to my list of plug-ins. Maybe I missed something though? I am really still figuring out this wordpress.org business — so I wouldn’t be surprised if I had.
My url is kaitmauro.com (the blog part that I want the plug-in on is kaitmauro.com/category/blog but it would be fine and good to have the button on all pages of the site).
Please let me know if you have any suggestions? I thought maybe the plug-in was just old and didn’t work anymore and I was very disappointed because I like having it there and I am losing so many readers from my old site on WordPress.com because they can’t follow this new one.
Cheers!
Kait
Once you’ve installed the plugin, you will want to clear the cache in your caching plugin, to make sure that the plugin is properly displayed on your site.
If that doesn’t help, I would suggest that you contact the plugin author here:
http://wordpress.org/support/plugin/follow-button-for-jetpack
This Follow button is not developed by our team, so I’m not sure I’ll be able to help you more.