Support » Alpha/Beta/RC » Improved Thumbnail Quality

  • For a long time, one of the things that has irritated me with WordPress is that I have to modify code with every release to have it generate decent quality thumbnails.

    If any of the developers read this, please consider looking closely at the following change for WP 2.3(Beta 2):

    File: /wp-admin/includes/image.php
    Line Number: approximately 84

    Change:

    if (!imagejpeg( $thumbnail, $thumbpath ) ) {

    To this:

    if (!imagejpeg( $thumbnail, $thumbpath, 100 ) ) {

    Note the 100 added. This will significantly improve the dreadful quality of the default thumbnails when large images are uploaded.

    Alternatively, making this a variable that can be defined in the Admin Options would allow people to choose the level of quality for their thumbnail.

Viewing 10 replies - 1 through 10 (of 10 total)
  • I’d suggest you join the hackers list where the devs hang out. They rarely read the forums…
    http://lists.automattic.com/mailman/listinfo/

    Thanks Moshu, but honestly, the last thing I want in my life is even more email to wade through, or another group to keep up with.

    I just thought that this being the Alpha/Beta forum, that the suggestion might get seen by developers, or might help others who may also be frustrated by the poor quality of the default thumbnails created by the inline WP uploader.

    No biggie, I’ll just keep editing with each release — it only takes a few seconds. Thanks for your response though.

    Les Bessant

    (@lesbessant)

    keeper of the Tiggers

    If you haven’t done so already, you could submit your request to the ideas forum:

    http://wordpress.org/extend/ideas/

    The devs do look there when deciding what features to add to future versions…

    Or you could Kvetch about it. Devs see that, too.

    Do *not* use value of 100 – this is the most inefficient JPEG compression possible! With 100 your thumbnail size will be several times larger with minimal visual improvement. In order to keep file size small and quality good enough – use values between 85 and 90.

    Futurix, which is why I suggested a variable be used so that end users could select which quality works for them.

    For me, I am uploading images with resolution of 1920pixels, and larger. Using a compression of 85 to 90 makes the generated thumbs look ridiculously bad.

    For this reason, I am using a variable of 100 and have super clean thumbs. The resulting thumbs are about 7 to 10k each versus the 2 or 3k crappy thumbs WordPress generates by default. From where I sit, 4 to 7k is a pretty small price to pay for decent looking thumbs compared to the horrible quality of the default ones.

    Quality matters.

    What kind of images are you using?

    I don’t see why it matters, as the end result is still that wordpress defaults produce ridiculously crappy thumbs unless you force the higher setting. So the type of pics I am uploading does not exactly matter, the end result is still the same — I have to edit core code to get a decent quality thumbnail to be created.

    That said, I’m using Jpegs (complex models) saved in resolutions of between 1920 and 3000 pixels (on their longest side). These files are saved with a Jpeg quality factor of about 85% from their original raw format, and are typically 1 to 2MB in file byte size.

    Incidentally, I understand compression versus quality loss — I’ve been working with graphics professionally for years.

    The simple fact is that relying on native PHP image resizing/resampling without specifying any quality options defaults to crappy thumbs. It’s bad enough that the thumb sizes/ratios are not selectable, but the thumb quality is so bad I can’t believe more people have not complained about it, as it’s embarrassingly bad quality.

    As such, the solution is to either edit code myself, or hope the developers actually include a user selectable quality variable for the generated thumbs.

    I can’t believe this has been added to the core yet.

    Why is it ALWAYS so hard to efficiently manage images with WordPress… things are getting better, but so slowly!

    It would be real nice to be able to adjust the the size of the thumbnails (I am modding my code right now to do this).

    things are getting better, but so slowly!
    I think so. But Don’t let this get you down.

    _______________________________________________________
    I want to learn: php Mysql blog of wordpres food of site

Viewing 10 replies - 1 through 10 (of 10 total)
  • The topic ‘Improved Thumbnail Quality’ is closed to new replies.