I tend to agree with other low ratings

I too find it looks terrible on phones. Disregarding that, just concerning with the desktop look, I found the theme is not so easy to work with compared to, say, the f2 theme (also free @ WP). So I tend to agree with others that say if you want it as is out-of-the-box, then OK, but I found myself spending too much time trying to crow-bar my objects into areas of the front page and not getting the results I wanted.