I Need 'Special Recent Posts' Plug-In to Overflow to New Pages

I am using the ‘Special Recent Posts’ plug-in in WordPress. It is being used to show header images and excerpts for articles, which you then click through to the full article.

You can set parameters on that plug-in to tell how many recent articles you would like show. Basically what I want to do is show the first five articles on the main page and then have the overflow go to new pages (like an ‘older posts’ type thing where there would be five posts per page).

Can anyone help me get pointed in the right direction? Every time I Google this question it doesn’t quite understand…Thanks.