I have settings configured but still gives access

Hi,

First off Thank You for making a free WordPress plugin. I know it can be a thankless thing to do. So I Thank You.

I have installed the plugin on this site http://sandiegoleaders.org/

I have the settings like this http://sandiegoleaders.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/01/Not_Working.png

and when I try to go to my profile when not logged in and any other BuddyPress page it still displays the pages.

i.e. http://sandiegoleaders.org/members/admin/profile/
http://sandiegoleaders.org/members/