Highlighted Post on Multiple Pages

Hey everyone,

I have a theme that displays the first post in full (example), and uses the “More…” function for the post below.

So, the latest post is in white and in full, and older posts are in grey and abbreviated.

However, on the 2nd page, the first post on that page is displayed in full and in white as well (I don’t want it to, I want it to be grey, since it’s not the most latest). (example)

Any ideas how I can do that?