Hide all content/pages/menus from non-subscribers

Hi,

I’ve build a simple social network and am looking for a simple way to hide all the content from non-members (subscribers).

http://community.littleredtarot.com

I’ve been exploring plugins such as ‘Eyes Only’ – these provide helpful shortcodes to make page content visible to members/non-members …but I have to go through every single page and wrap all contents in order to do this.

Plus, it doesn’t hide widgets/menus, or blog posts, so content is still accessible to non-members.

IDEALLY:
I’d like something than means you cannot get beyond the home page unless you’re a member.

Thanks for any suggestions!

Beth