Global Diasble Working, On Page Enable Not Working

I was able to activate the plugin and moved the Plugin Organizer MU to the Must-Use Plugins folder. I was able to turn “Selective Plugin Loading” on and keep it on after leaving the plugin settings and returning.

But when I go to edit the specific page and enable a plugin, it turns green, but it still is disabled when viewing the page. I’ve cleared my cache and tried deactivating and re-activating the plugin, but it will not work.

While troubleshooting, I also realized that my “Post Type Plugins” tab under the plugin settings is not loading. When the page tries to load, I’ll see the tables start to load, but then they disappear to a blank screen.

This makes me think there is a bigger issue going on aside from the Selective Plugin Loading not working on individual pages.

Please let me know if you have any ideas about what could be going wrong. Thanks!