WordPress.org

Support

Support » Plugins and Hacks » feature comparison

feature comparison

Viewing 5 replies - 1 through 5 (of 5 total)
  • Plugin Author nintechnet

    @nintechnet

    It seems that the plugin you mentioned is only acting like… a plugin.
    That is the problem with most security plugins:
    1) requests will need to get through WordPress before reaching the plugin (HTTP server -> PHP -> WordPress -> plugin). That means that the core part of WordPress is not protected as it needs to be loaded first.
    2) it will protect the index page only (and probably the admin index too). It there is a vulnerable PHP script on the server or a backdoor, it won’t be protected.

    NinjaFirewall will protect any PHP script and will hook the request before WordPress is loaded (HTTP server -> PHP -> NinjaFirewall -> WordPress).
    It does not rely on WordPress to work. Only the admin UI needs WordPress for the installation and configuration.

    Thanks. I had a look here: http://ninjafirewall.com/overview.html and was unsure whether I should go for the free edition or the WordPress edition.

    I am on my own root server and only host WP.

    WP or Free? It looks like the WP edition has more features?

    Plugin Author nintechnet

    @nintechnet

    The Free and Pro versions have more features and can handle multiple PHP applications (e.g. an OSCommerce shop + a WP or Joomla blog etc).
    But if you need protection for WordPress only, the WP edition should be perfect.

    So do I get this right? You had a look at that other plugin and it acts like a plugin?

    Because I saw this article: http://www.howtoforge.com/intrusion-detection-for-php-applications-with-phpids

    explaining how to load PHPIDS with every PHP script. That’s exactly the way ninjafirewall does it.

    What about the blocking mechanisms both firewalls use?

    Plugin Author nintechnet

    @nintechnet

    If you can use PHPIDS that way, then it will work too. But I don’t know whether you still need the mute-screamer plugin or not?

Viewing 5 replies - 1 through 5 (of 5 total)
  • The topic ‘feature comparison’ is closed to new replies.