Facebook preview link is something completely different

One of the users of my sites recently wrote me saying that when he tried to share a link from my site that is showed as something completely different. I tried and, it does it for every page but the main one. Here is the link that I’ll use here as an example: http://www.tophattwaffle.com/?page_id=61

This is what is does: http://i.imgur.com/LFku1.png

I’ve updated all of my plugins, removed all ad sources from the site. And even disabled all of my plugins. Nothing works. Any help would be wonderful!