I updated just to make sure that wouldn't fix the issue, but upgrading to WP 3.6 didn't help. I enable the plugin and my site doesn't display. I can't leave it enabled as I would like my site to work *grin* but the site is katscafe.org
I'm happy to troubleshoot anything you think might be helpful or you can email/contact me directly from my site if you need access to my site to try to replicate the problem.
Katrina "Kat" Moody