I just installed the PlugIn and tried to subscribe myself with an email that is not subscribed yet, it doesn't work tho.
I went through the posts here and checked everything but I still don't get it fixed.
So I created a page, added the form by clicking on that s2 button and linked that page to the subscriber settings as well as the widget.
The "send e-mail from" author thing is correct too (I had that error msg first that it doesn't fit to the domain, but I fixed it) and the SMTP is smtp.paperflutterby.de.
Yet, when I try to subscribe myself the subscribtion form page simply reloads again and nothing else happens, no email received, no msg about new subscriber etc.
What am I doing wrong?
Here's my website: http://paperflutterby.de/?