Hi,
The issue may be related to the mail client that the users have.
Could you please try to use the Gmail address to open the reply to users message to see whether the issue will occur again?
Please note that in the WordPress.org forum we are replying to the free product related question only. For the further questions regarding the Premium version, please contact our support team using the following email address: support@web-dorado.com
Thanks. Have a nice day.