I belonged to Elegant themes for a full year, but am no longer a member so I can't access their forum to get the fix for my theme :(
That's a problem as we don't support commercial themes here. We don't have access to the theme either, nor want access truth be told.
Give this a read as it couldn't hurt.
Also try deactivating all your plugins and switch to the Twenty Eleven theme just to confirm it's your theme. Reactivate the plugins and confirm that the "Cheatin huh?" has gone away without using your theme.
If it is the theme (and I'm pretty sure it is) then you'll need to either update or switch to a different theme.