Disable contextual matching – Still matching contexts

I’ve selected the above option, to disable all contextual matches and just match tags. I’ve setup posts to be the only matched items, and its almost working. It’s so close, but it just will not under any circumstance pull up a page. The only reason it’s not pulling it: its a different format from the others. It’s not using the same headings, it’s not using the same information. But I’ve disabled it, why is it still looking at context instead of my tags?

The page it should pull up most every time should be Your Campsite, and Central Program. But it doesn’t show Central Program ever. Is there something I’m missing?

The page I need help with: [log in to see the link]