I love the subscribe2 plugin... it just doesn't love me back...
I cannot get the confirmation email to send when someone initially subscribes.
I've spent days trying to figure out a fix on my own including using the WP-Mail-SMTP plugin, changing the email address to match the domain, and any number or different settings on the back-end.
Basically, emails do send and when someone subscribes their address does shows up under "public subscribers", it just stays unconfirmed. I'm using godaddy which seems to be a common denominator, but I'm wondering if I'm missing something simple. Any help would be greatly appreciated.