On my website, clicking on any of the Recent Comments that are located on pages with large numbers of comments exceeding paginate settings (50 comments, in this case) present erroneous permalinks (with wrong page numbers). Only the posts containing enough comments on page 3 or higher present these improperly constructed links that take users to the wrong page (a page that does not contain the comment in question). The problem does not occur on pages containing a limited number of comments. So far, we have removed our Thesis theme and changed to the standard WP default theme. And we've deactivated all plugins. Yet neither solution appears to resolve the issue. Thanks for your consideration. Please view this issue live at http://www.dogfoodadvisor.com
Thanks for your help.