Everything appears as it should and seems to work fine, until you try and post a comment, and it merely reloads the post with no comment, and no evidence of the comment anywhere.
I was using 2.3.2 and it is a new site, so I am not sure if they ever worked, but I figured I would start by upgrading to 2.3.3 and see if that helped, no such luck.
I have tried it with several different themes with no luck, and with all of the plugins disabled.
This site is hosted by lunar hosting, I have another basic test wp site setup on a separate hosting companies server, and the comments work as they should there, with any theme.
Maybe from running .htaccess from the root as opposed to from /wordpress... everything else seems to work fine.
Your thoughts are appreciated.