CF7 Integration Unable to Find Email Field

I’m having a similar problem to this post: wordpress.org/support/topic/cf7-integration-multi-step-form-unable-to-find-email-field/

My Debug log also reads: “[2019-03-14 12:40:01] WARNING: Contact Form 7 > Unable to find EMAIL field.”

I’m pretty new at this so I’m sure I’m making a common error. The form tag names and required fields match exactly between CF7 and Mailchimp, i.e. EMAIL, FNAME, LNAME, etc. All fields, including email, are populated when I submit the form as a test. I receive a confirmation at the email I entered in the EMAIL field through CF7, so it is going through, just not to Mailchimp.

Here’s how I have the form set up in CF7:
<label> Your Email (required)
[email* EMAIL] </label>

<label> Your First Name (required)
[text* FNAME] </label>

<label> Your Last Name (required)
[text* LNAME] </label>

<label> Your Phone Number
[tel PHONE] </label>

<label> Subject
[text SUBJECT] </label>

[honeypot email id:required]

<label> Your Message
[textarea MESSAGE minlength:10 maxlength:500] </label>

[mc4wp_checkbox]

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

[submit “Send”]

Any help is really appreciated.

The page I need help with: [log in to see the link]