I am using the Insignia theme. My website is at http://www.the-college-reporter.com.
The problem I am having is in each category for the sections of our newspaper, clickable by way of the header links, News, Op-Eds, Campus Life, Arts & Entertainment, and Sports, there are between 6 and 10 pages of posts, but the website will only return the first ten posts over and over again.
A relevant link is: http://www.the-college-reporter.com/category/op-ed/
This page looks the same/pulls up the same stories as does the link: http://www.the-college-reporter.com/category/op-ed/page/5/
The only way to reach the older stories is to search for them. This is problematic for users looking at the website for its use, which is as the online version of our campus newspaper. I have tried removing all custom coding but nothing seems to help. A web editor noticed the issue a few weeks ago so I can not point to a specific modification of the site that lead to this problem.