I'm new to WordPress, so please bare with me ;)
I started my website a few weeks ago. I wanted to add a Twitter Follow me button, so I downloaded, installed, and activated the Twitter follow me button. My home page displays one Twitter button (but it's not the follow me button, instead it opens a tweet with my page's link) and the rest of my pages displays 2 buttons that open a tweet.
I'm sure it's something very easy to fix...
Here's my website: http://www.cindyindybones.com