Awesome Comment Plugin

  • WutHirsch

    (@wuthirsch)


    9 years, 1 month ago

    This plugin is awesome.

    It’s not perfect yet, but still one of the best comment plugins i have seen yet. Works good with a lot of other plugins, i use on my site.

    So if a user clicks on the last comment section, the plugin dont show his comment. The wanted comment is a little above the showed comment. It’s a little bit confusing. Cant’t say it’s a problem related with my theme (Mythemeshop) or another problem.

    There are some things i would love too see in the future:
    -Better Antispam Feature, maybe an AntispamBee Compatibility
    (5 Spam Comments gets through the anti spam, and the plugin cause some false postives. (Comments from my registered Users)
    -Show how many Votes the comment author has become yet. (Maybe in the profile section?)

    Keep up the good work!

    EDIT: See the comments below..
    5 Star Rating now.

Viewing 5 replies - 1 through 5 (of 5 total)
  • Plugin Author gVectors Team

    (@gvectors-team)

    9 years, 1 month ago

    Hi WutHirsch,
    Thank you for the good review.

    So if a user clicks on the last comment section, the plugin dont show his comment. The wanted comment is a little above the showed comment. It’s a little bit confusing. Cant’t say it’s a problem related with my theme (Mythemeshop) or another problem.

    So you think this is a fair reason to decrease plugin rate from 5* to 4*?

    There are some things i would love too see in the future:
    -Better Antispam Feature, maybe an AntispamBee Compatibility
    (5 Spam Comments gets through the anti spam, and the plugin cause some false postives. (Comments from my registered Users)
    -Show how many Votes the comment author has become yet. (Maybe in the profile section?)

    Sure, there are hundreds of features can be added in this plugin, but please do not decrease plugin rating based on a new feature you’d like to have on it. Plugin does what it says it does – but plugin doesn’t do what it doesn’t say it does… So if all works fine what are described on plugin page it should not be rated as 4*

    Using the review system as a way to get new things added into plugins may annoy plugin authors. If you are requesting a feature then I’d suggest you do it in the support forum.

    We’ve also had such a discussion in this Review Thread:
    https://wordpress.org/support/topic/so-far-so-good-145?replies=15#post-

    —
    Thank you very much for your understanding
    gVectors Team

    Thread Starter WutHirsch

    (@wuthirsch)

    9 years, 1 month ago

    Hello gVectors Team,

    thank you for your fast response.

    I didn’t decreased the rating because of missing features or because of features i wish to see.

    A perfect plugin becomes a 5 stars rating, wpDiscuz is a good plugin and i think that 4 stars are a good Rating too.

    The main reason was the integrated antispam Feature, that cause some problems for my use and results in false positives.

    Also it was my first review on wordpress.org. It seems there is no button to change this rating anymore. I wanted to watch the further development and change this rating later. So im sorry. 4,5 of 5 Stars.

    Plugin Author gVectors Team

    (@gvectors-team)

    9 years, 1 month ago

    Ok, thank you very much for the clarification.

    The main reason was the integrated antispam Feature, that cause some problems for my use and results in false positives.

    wpDiscuz uses core WP Comment Creator functions, those are hooked with all available antispam systems you currently use. So it should work fine, because wpDiscuz doesn’t have any relation with new comment insert core process. wpDiscuz just gets comment data and sends to WordPress insert_comment function. So you can install and configure any antispam plugin, all should work fine, because all work with this WordPress core function.

    Thread Starter WutHirsch

    (@wuthirsch)

    9 years ago

    Hello gVectors Team,

    thank you very much for your clarification too.

    So it seems the problem caused by antispambee and not of Wpdiscuz.
    The problem occurred after installing “wpdiscuz”, maybe I reacted too early.

    Also i changed the rating to 5 Stars (found the edit button), because you guys do a great job and plugin here and your clarifications explained the problem.

    Thank you.

    Plugin Author gVectors Team

    (@gvectors-team)

    9 years ago

    Great!
    Thank you very much WutHirsch,
    Such reviews really encourage us to make this plugin better and better.

Viewing 5 replies - 1 through 5 (of 5 total)
  • The topic ‘Awesome Comment Plugin’ is closed to new replies.