We are still testing our new BuddyPress site when we run into this issue.
One user kept entering their login incorrectly and after so many times it locked them out. Then I tried logging into one of the WP Admins and it was locked out as well. Then I try to login with several other logins and on the first attempt to login with what is 100% the login info I get taken to the same /?login=false page.
I changed the name of the /theme-my-login/ directory(to disable) and then went to /wp-admin/ and tried to login with the Administrator credentials. It says that the account is locked and to wait 30 minutes and try again.
I see people having this same problem with this plug-in on a few other places throughout google but no real solution. Have you found one for this problem? We plan on having a lot of members, how could ONE member lock EVERY member's account because they typed it in wrong so many times. How can a Subscriber attempting to login cause the MAIN Admin to be locked out?
Is there a way to fix this issue? Besides deleting your plug-in? I really like the plug-in and would like to use it but this is a problem.
Will update after I try and login again.
Thanks in advance.